Homemade Oreo Cookies

Homemade Oreo Cookies recipe from weelicious.com

OREOS!! The greatest box snack of all time (or at least in my humble opinion). I went through a phase a few years ago of making all of my favorite packaged foods into homemade versions and these Homemade Oreo Cookies were at the top of the list. Now that Kenya and Chloe are older I thought I would try them again since they have tasted the Trader Joes version and know just how addictive they can be. If you like the Oreos you grew up on I bet you're going to become totally obsessed with the Weelicious Homemade Oreo Cookies. Crunchy chocolate cookies with a creamy center that's so similar in taste yet that much more fresh since you made them with love in your own kitchen. For this rewind Wednesday I'm bringing back one of my all time favorites!

Homemade Oreo Cookies recipe from weelicious.com

As soon as I was old enough to bike to the grocery by myself with a pocket full of change, I was buying Oreo Cookies. I was obsessed with them. My mom didn't let us have packaged cookies or other treats when I was growing up, so I'm sure that only made me want them even more.

In high school, my friends and I would buy a half pound bag after school and sit around twisting apart the chocolate cookies, making the monumental decision of whether to first lick off the thick creamy center stuck to one side or devour the unadorned crunchy cookie side instead. I don't remember a ton of moments from, say, science class, but I sure do remember eating a lot of Oreos.

Homemade Oreo Cookies recipe from weelicious.com

Even though I don't buy Oreos anymore, I still dream about them. One day I decided to stop fantasizing and come up with my own take on an Oreo that I'd feel good about letting my kids eat. My husband doubted I could replicate the classic taste and experience of the classic, but I plowed ahead and came up with a recipe.

Homemade Oreo Cookies recipe from weelicious.com

Oh. My. Goodness. This homemade version is crazy good. And the part I love most is that you can use cookie cutters to make homemade oreos in an unlimited array of shapes.

Instead of depriving kids of sweets entirely, get into the kitchen and make them something special like these delectable treats. Your little ones won't have an easier time deciding which side of the cookie to eat first, but you will certainly feel better about them eating these than what you'd buy in the store.

Homemade Oreo Cookies recipe from weelicious.com

Photos by Matt Armendariz

comment on this post

Homemade Oreo Cookies (makes 30 sandwich cookies)

Prep Time: 10 mins Cook Time: 12 mins

nut free

Ingredients

  • 1 1/4 cups white wheat flour
  • 1/2 cup Cocoa Powder
  • 1 teaspoon Baking Soda
  • 1/4 teaspoon Salt
  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter, cubed and chilled
  • 1/2 cup brown sugar
  • 1/2 cup White Sugar
  • 1 Large Egg
  • 1/4 cup vegetable shortening
  • 1/4 cup unsalted butter, room temperature
  • 1/4 cup powdered sugar

Preparation

1. Preheat oven to 350 ℉.

2. Sift together the flour, cocoa powder, baking soda, and salt. Place in the bowl of a food processor.

3. Add the chilled and cubed butter and the white and brown sugars to the food processor and pulse until it resembles coarse meal. Add the egg and continue to pulse until a dough forms.

4. Roll the dough between two pieces of parchment paper or on a lightly floured surface until 1/4 inch thick and cut out cookies with a 2-inch scalloped edged round cookie cutter, or any of your favorite cutters.

5. Bake for 12-15 minutes. Cookies will be soft at first, but harden as they cool.

6. In the bowl of a standing mixer or with an electric mixer, cream together the shortening and butter, then gradually add the powdered sugar until the filling is soft and fluffy.

7. Spread 1 teaspoon of filling onto half of the cookies and sandwich together with the remaining cookies.

Make N' Share!
Post a picture of any Weelicious recipe you make on Instagram - I wanna see them! Just tag @weelicious
Hi, I’m Catherine. Mama of three. A Kentucky girl living in California. Here’s what I know: all kids can be great eaters and mealtime must be easy. My passion is creating simple, healthy recipes that can be enjoyed by the whole family.

leave a comment

54 comments

  • Ruth

    Yes! Can't wait to try these! Assuming only one egg?

    leave a comment

    • Catherine

      Yes, 1 egg!

      leave a comment

  • Serena Ross

    My son is crazy about Oreos, so I would love to try these! He is allergic to dairy though. Do you think I could substitute earth balance vegan sticks for the butter?

    leave a comment

    • Catherine

      Yes, Earth Balance is a great butter substitute!

      leave a comment

  • Natasha

    This is great! Thanks for this. Can't wait to get started, but want to clarify the egg. Only one? It's not listed in the ingredients.

    Thanks again!

    leave a comment

    • Catherine

      Yes, 1 egg! I've updated the recipe!

      leave a comment

  • Natasha

    Also...just wondering....do you think I could sub coconut oil for the shortening? That's what the white filling is made of. At least it is here in Canada.

    Thanks!

    leave a comment

    • Rebecca

      I would like to know a valid substitute, as well. Can't wait to try these.

      leave a comment

    • Catherine

      I have not tried it with coconut oil, but it might work. You might need to add more sugar to make it thick enough, but give it a try!

      leave a comment

    • Sarah

      I used coconut oil instead of the shortening and it worked out pretty well. I did have to add more sugar, otherwise it tasted too oily (plus I added vanilla extract because I was trying to cover up the coconut taste for a picky eater - I thought it still had a bit of a coconut flavor, but he didn't notice and loved them).

      leave a comment

  • Laurel

    Speechless with excitement....

    leave a comment

    • Haresh

      Hi. My name is Jan from bobbypinsboardwalk. You have some dnlirag ideas on your blog, and I'm going to sign up to follow. I invite you to visit my blog and do likewise! I look forward to being further inspired :)

      leave a comment

  • Meghna

    This is by far, probably, the coolest recipe you have ever posted! Thanks so much!

    leave a comment

  • Dorothy

    I don't have a food processor. Do you think I could use a pastry cutter instead and still get the same consistency?

    leave a comment

    • Catherine

      Yes! You could even use your fingertips to gently mash the butter into the flour and sugars to form the coarse meal consistency!

      leave a comment

  • Stefanie

    Oh my gosh, that is so funny! I was just looking up recipes for homemade oreos last week. Can't wait to try yours!

    leave a comment

  • Lindsey L.

    So excited to try this . I had a different recipe I was going to try tomorrow . I will try yours instead. Thank you for sharing

    leave a comment

    • Sherry

      Hi Ashley, thank you so much for the delicious repcie for making Oreo Bark. Talk about decadent!! I'm going to make it sometime soon. I have recently found your blog and am now following you, and will visit often. Please stop by my blog and perhaps you would like to follow me also. Have a wonderful day. Hugs, Chris

      leave a comment

  • Madeleine

    Wow, these look great! Can't wait to try out the recipe - I love oreos too!

    leave a comment

  • Sarah

    These are great! I had to make them without my food processor and I probably wouldn't do that again. After adding the egg they were still way too dry so I had to add another egg and it made them a bit too sticky. I think the food processor would have eliminated the initial dryness. Other than that, they turned out great. Oh, and I won't use shortening so I subbed coconut oil and ended up having to add more powdered sugar to the filling, which really wasn't a big deal since so little filling is used per cookie. However, to compensate for that extra sugar, I only used 2/3 cup of sugar in the cookie dough (I only had organic cane sugar so didn't do brown and white). They were plenty sweet with the sugar reduction in the dough, so I'd definitely make them that way again.

    leave a comment

    • Ruth

      I had the same problem with the dough as Sarah, and I used a food processor. Too dry, but after adding 1 t vanilla and 2 T water, it was sticky and even stuck to the parchment paper. Ended up getting them made and they taste good. Made some w/ the filling in the recipe. The rest we filled with a pumpkin, cream cheese, and powder sugar mixture for Halloween.

      leave a comment

  • Stacie

    These look delish! I was also dreaming of oatmeal cream pies
    The other day. Any thoughts on a recipe?

    leave a comment

    • Catherine

      Hmmm that's a good one! I'll have to start working on it!

      leave a comment

  • Lisa With Style And Grace

    love the idea of making these at home!

    leave a comment

  • Copycat Lofthouse Sugar Cookies, Copycat Oreos, Spinach Balls, Pizza Margherita, And Migraine Muffins…made With l♥ve By The Cookie Mama.

    [...] http://b12.ba4.myftpupload.com/2012/10/10/oreo-cookies-yes-you-can-make-them-at-home/ [...]

    leave a comment

  • Aman

    These chocolate cookies may work for ice cream sandwiches!

    leave a comment

  • Laurie

    Do you store these in the refrigerator or out?

    leave a comment

    • Catherine

      I stored them in an airtight container on the counter for three days!

      leave a comment

  • Amy Z

    Not like oreos at all actually.

    leave a comment

  • David

    Can i substitute the shortening for just vegetable oil and i not what can i substitute it for?

    leave a comment

    • Catherine

      The shortening is for the filling so oil won't work for that. You could use all butter and add a little vanilla extract to make it more of a classic buttercream frosting!

      leave a comment

  • Amy Z

    Oh wait....I made a second batch and cooked them longer than I thought I should be cooked. They came out soft but got hard once cooled. And they tasted like Oreos! Sorry for doubting you Catherine - let's chalk it up to \"operator error\".

    leave a comment

  • Null

    I've quickly become a fan of your recipes!

    leave a comment

  • Ctgirl

    Cool!

    leave a comment

  • Ctgirl

    How do u come up with all these cool recipes?

    leave a comment

    • Catherine

      Lots of sitting around dreaming about foods! It's a rough life. ;)

      leave a comment

  • Nina

    Made these today with my 3 year old, they are amazing!!! Both she and my son loved them. Thanks so much, one more step in our endeavor to cut out processed foods.

    leave a comment

  • Danielle

    Can I sub some of the flour for coconut flour? Also raw honey and coconut oil for some of the shortening and sugar to make up the frosting?

    leave a comment

  • Korean Sweet Treat Hwa Jeon With Honey And Flower Petals • Taste With The Eyes • Where The Image Is Meant To Titillate And Inspire The Cook

    […] Cookies with Meyer Lemon Curd Elephants and the Coconut Trees: French Palmiers Weelicious: Homemade Oreo Cookies Devour: Top 5 Chocolate Cookies Taste With The Eyes: A Korean Sweet Treat – Hwa Jeon with […]

    leave a comment

  • Peanut Butter And Jelly Thumbprint Quinoa Oat Cookies Recipe Jeanette's Healthy Living

    […] Cookies with Meyer Lemon Curd Elephants and the Coconut Trees: French Palmiers Weelicious: Homemade Oreo Cookies Devour: Top 5 Chocolate Cookies Taste With The Eyes: A Korean Sweet Treat – Hwa Jeon with […]

    leave a comment

  • Liz Virtually Homemade

    These look so wonderful - much better than packaged :) Fun contributing to Comfort Food Feast with you :)

    leave a comment

  • Cookie Comfort — Comfort Food Feast Sheknowslatino

    […] Cookies with Meyer Lemon Curd Elephants and the Coconut Trees: French Palmiers Weelicious: Homemade Oreo Cookies Devour: Top 5 Chocolate Cookies Taste With The Eyes: A Korean Sweet Treat – Hwa Jeon with […]

    leave a comment

  • Rose And Cardamon Nankhatai Eggless Indian Shortbread Cookies

    […] with Meyer Lemon Curd Elephants and the Coconut Trees: French Palmiers Weelicious: Homemade Oreo Cookies Devour: Top 5 Chocolate Cookies Taste With The Eyes: A Korean Sweet Treat – Hwa […]

    leave a comment

  • Jane, The Heritage Cook

    These are absolutely adorable and I LOVE that you can use cookie cutters to make a variety of shapes. So Fun!!!

    leave a comment

  • Homemade Treats: Recipes For Favorite Store-Bought Snacks And Goodies

    […] From Weelicious […]

    leave a comment

  • Silke

    Dear Catherine,
    I don't use white flour for my kids (except in play dough). Have you tried a whole wheat version? Is there anything else that could make them a little healthier (something about replacing part of the shortening or butter, or all that sugar)?

    leave a comment

    • McCord

      I haven't tested this recipe with whole wheat flour, but I think it would work out just fine. You may need to reduce the flour by about 2-4 tablespoons so that the dough isn't too dry. Let me know if you try it and how it comes out!

      leave a comment

  • Myriah

    These look so delish!! Any chance you be made the filling with something other than vegetable shortening?

    leave a comment

    • McCord

      The vegetable shortening is what gives the filling that classic fluffiness! You can find some great ones on the market these days like Spectrum. :)

      leave a comment

  • Lina

    Isn't too much sugar?

    leave a comment

  • Sylvia

    I was also wondering if you could substitute coconut sugar for the white sugar at least. I think it is always a shock at howuch sugar it takes to make it taste like an American favorite! Since I gave my kids Oreos in their lunch box yesterday as a treat I will be trying this version for sure. Thanks for posting! Always love getting rid of packaged junk.

    leave a comment

    • McCord

      I haven't tested this recipe with coconut sugar, but as it acts very much like white sugar, I think it is worth a try! Let me know if you try it and how it comes out!

      leave a comment

  • Robin Bouplon

    Which vegetable shortening do you use?

    leave a comment

    • McCord

      Spectrum!

      leave a comment