The night I gave birth to Chloe all I wanted afterwards was a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Call me a girl with simple taste, but it’s true — I only craved thick, sliced sandwich bread, toasted and slathered with tons of smooth peanut butter and fresh strawberry preserves. I forgot one thing. It had to be made in a waffle iron!
If you’ve never had a PB&J made this way, you are missing out. I literally dreamed about having this “push” sandwich for weeks prior to Chloe arriving. Hours after she was born and resting in my arms, I gobbled up not one, but two. After all, I felt like I had more than earned it!
When you want to impress someone with your incredible culinary skills, whip up one of these ooeey-gooey, delectable treats.
Photo by Maren Caruso

The World’s Greatest Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich
Ingredients
- 2 slices sandwich bread
- 2 tablespoons peanut butter
- 2 tablespoons preserves
- butter, optional
Instructions
- Preheat a waffle iron.
- Spread about 2 tablespoons of peanut butter (more if you want) on one slice of bread.
- Spread about 2 tablespoons of preserves or jelly on another slice of bread. Place the peanut butter covered slice of bread on top to make a sandwich.
- Lightly butter your waffle iron (optional), place the sandwich inside and close.
- Cook the sandwich for 4-5 minutes or until bread is golden and filling is oozing out the sides.
[…] Virtually Homemade: Mini Nutter Butter Baked Donuts with Chocolate Ganache Weelicious: World’s Greatest Peanut Butter and Jelly In Jennie’s Kitchen: Peanut Butter & Chocolate Cinnamon Buns Red or Green: Peanut […]
[…] Virtually Homemade: Mini Nutter Butter Baked Donuts with Chocolate Ganache Weelicious: World’s Greatest Peanut Butter and Jelly In Jennie’s Kitchen: Peanut Butter & Chocolate Cinnamon Buns Red or Green: Peanut Butter […]
This will be so much fun for my son with our Mickey waffle iron! Thank you for the idea, I never would have thought to use the waffle iron on a PB&J sandwich, and with the ice storm that just hit, this will be a nice warm treat.
I know this is an older recipe, but we just tried it for the first time today. I thought it would be a fun snow day treat. My son wanted cream cheese and jelly instead and I made the traditional PB&J for my daughter. Both were delicious and a big hit. Thanks!
love your recipes
[…] I got this ingenious idea from Weelicious, a great resource for healthy, kid-friendly meals. Here’s a link to the original post. […]
[…] fun to mix things up. I recently saw an article in the newspaper about a PBRB sandwich, inspired by Weelicious. It got me thinking about a bunch of variations for the PB&J, and I thought I’d share a […]
[…] just consistent practice and becoming familiar with new things. Any class with an allusion to Peanut Butter and Jelly sandwiches has my vote (#PBandJterm all the […]
This is my waffle iron and I am very happy with it! http://astore.amazon.com/weelicious-20/detail/B0002CA39Y
What brand of waffle iron do you use and are you happy with it? I have purchased three different brands and am currently using the Crusinart round waffle iron. Your looks very good. Thanks.
If you don’t have a waffle iron, don’t let that deter you from enjoying this, just fry it up like a grilled cheese sandwich on a skillet – slather a little butter on the outside bread, and it gets all goey and delicious! I’ve enjoyed them this way for years. Now I almost wish I hadn’t already started dinner tonight… 🙂
[…] another spin-off on grilled PB&J. The clever implementation of a waffle iron imprints the finished product with a neat […]
My kids didn’t eat peanut butter & jelly sandwiches until just now! This was such an easy twist to break from the sandwich rut!! Thank you 🙂
Just made this for lunch and it was the most yummy sandwich I’ve ever tasted! Thank you for this fabulous idea!!
This is the one I have. I love it, and I store it up in a cabinet and take it down only to use it. http://astore.amazon.com/weelicious-20/detail/B0002CA39Y
This looks incredible. Catherine, is there a waffle iron you recommend? I don’t have much counter space so I would love one that is easy to store and take out for use. Thanks!