Thanksgiving Menu and a Step-by-Step Prep Schedule

THE Best Thanksgiving Menu

• The Best Brined Turkey
• Turkey Gravy
• Cornbread Cranberry Stuffing
• Cranberry Orange Sauce 
• Maple Roast Vegetables 
• Mascarpone Mashed Potatoes
• Shredded Brussels Sprouts with Lemon and Poppy Seeds or Apple, Pear and Goat Cheese Fall Salad
• Classic Macaroni and Cheese
• Sweet Potatoes in Orange Cups 
• Maple Pumpkin Pie 
• Apple Pie or Gluten-Free Apple Pie

ONE-TWO WEEKS IN ADVANCE

• Plan your menu. Here are the bones of a Thanksgiving dinner, essentially. A turkey (or other main dish like roast chicken), a stuffing, a salad, a potato (or two), a vegetable, another hearty side (depending on the size of your get together) and a few desserts. I change out which ones I do every year, but the categories stay about the same.
• Order the turkey: If you’re planning on ordering a turkey in advance from a local butcher, go ahead and do that. If you’re getting one from the grocery store you could go ahead and get one and store it in your freezer if you have the room but you can wait until the week of. You’ll want about 1.25 pounds of turkey per person.
• Source serving dishes and decor: Take stock of what dishes and decor you have and what you’ll need for serving. Buy or borrow what you may be missing. Here’s a list of everything I use every Thanksgiving.
• Divide and conquer: If you’re planning on going potluck style and having guests bring certain dishes, go ahead and assign dishes to everyone so they know what they’re bringing.

THE WEEK BEFORE

• Clean and Organize. Clean out your refrigerator/pantry. Toss expired foods and make room for new food coming in. Starting with a fresh, clean kitchen will help make everything else run smoothly. 
• Grocery shop: Do the bulk of your grocery shopping, especially items that are shelf stable or won’t go bad quickly. There’s nothing worse than going grocery shopping the week of Thanksgiving and not being able to get all the ingredients you need! 

THANKSGIVING WEEK PREP PLAN

This is a step by step guide on what I’ll be doing the week of thanksgiving based on our menu this year. Follow along or take ideas if you want! 

Monday:

• Pick up your turkey from your local butcher or grocery store and finish grocery shopping for other ingredients you need. If you purchased a frozen turkey, store it in the refrigerator to start thawing.

Tuesday:

• Start your day by brining the bird using my Best Brined Turkey recipe (“the most moist and juicy turkey you’ve ever tasted,” says my turkey-obsessed father-in-law). If your turkey is thawing, you can still go ahead and start brining it. It’ll thaw as it brines. You could also opt for Herb Brined Turkey or Maple Brined Turkey!

Wednesday:

I try to do the bulk of my cooking/prepping on Wednesday so I can take my time a bit on Thursday. Thanksgiving Day is normally quiet with so few distractions (besides the anticipation of the big meal ahead of us) and I hate having to spend all of it in the kitchen. I also find that once the major work is out of the way, it’s a great time to get the kids involved in the final tasks and really let them feel like they’re a part of the meal. With extra time on Thursday too it’s a good opportunity to make Thanksgiving Turkey Pretzels together.

• Set the table with flowers, candles, feathers and festive napkin rings.
• Prepare Cranberry Orange Sauce and store in the refrigerator.
• Chop parsnips, a mix of bell peppers, onions, carrots and delicata squash for Maple Roast Veggies. Coat them in olive oil and spices and store in a ziplock bag in the refrigerator until Thursday.
• Make the filling for Sweet Potatoes in Orange Cups. Finish them up on Thanksgiving Day. You can also prep them entirely and then just bake them tomorrow if you have the room to store them in your refrigerator on a baking sheet.
• Bake the cornbread and prep the stuffing (through step 3 of this recipe), refrigerating the vegetables overnight. If you’re making Apple Sausage Stuffing Bites, you can prep the mixture and refrigerate then scoop and bake on Thanksgiving day.
• After the kids go to bed, bake Maple Pumpkin Pie and Apple Pie (my favorite time to bake is at night). If I don’t have time to make the pies entirely, I go ahead and make the pie dough and store it in the refrigerator to be ready to roll out Thursday morning and finish the pies.

Thursday, Thanksgiving Day: 

We eat dinner at 5pm every year, so here’s a step-by-step guide to our day. It might look slightly different for you, but generally this is the order of operations for us!

• 8:00am: Make Maple Pumpkin Pie and Apple Pie. If you already made them last night, woohoo!
• 9:30am: Remove the Turkey from the brine, dry thoroughly and roast, starting at step 5 of this recipe.
• 10:00am: Get everything chopped and ready for the Shredded Brussel Sprouts with Lemon and Poppy Seeds or Apple, Pear Goat Cheese Fall Salad. 
• 10:45am: Finish assembling Sweet Potatoes in Orange Cups if necessary. Finish the cornbread stuffing so you can pop it in the oven as soon as the turkey is done. Make the Mascarpone Mashed Potatoes and get Classic Mac and Cheese ready to be baked after the turkey is done.
• 12:30pm: Remove turkey from the oven and let it rest. Roast the Maple Roast Vegetables, allow to cool, and cover. 
• 1:30pm: Put the Cornbread Cranberry Stuffing into the oven. You can bake the sweet potatoes in orange cups and the mac and cheese at the same time as the stuffing. Just set a timer for each one. While the stuffing, sweet potatoes and mac and cheese (and any other baked sides you’re making) are in the oven, make the turkey gravy.
• 3:30pm – 4:00pm: Finishing touches on table setting, carve the turkey and set out all the food.
• 5:00pm: Dinner time! Enjoy!
• 7:00pm: Become a superhero host and offer compostable to-go containers for leftovers.

Finally, there’s a family tradition we have which everyone who comes over really enjoys participating in. Before dinner we have everyone anonymously write on a piece of paper what they’re thankful for and put it into a hat or bowl. After dinner, we go around the table and have each person pick out one note and read it aloud. Then everyone tries to guess who wrote what. It’s not only a fun game, but also a beautiful way to relish the most important part of the holiday, being together!